First, the positives - the host was very friendly on the phone and very kind - he delivered a dozen fresh oysters to our camp and set us up with firewood and a grate to cook them. That was so incredibly kind. Thank you.
Unfortunately, there were some big negatives for our site #3. I think the host means well, but in practice, we felt misled by the listing. At the time we booked our site, the only pictures showed a secluded site in the woods. Site #3 was right next to the road, in a gravel parking lot, next to a pole barn and some heavy machinery parked nearby. It had services and a picnic table and fire ring, but definitely not a cozy site in the woods. There were 2 other sites occupied, and the one above us in the woods seemed to match the photos, but site #3 was not as advertised. Also, there were no directions to help the camper know which site to go to. We arrived in the dark and didn't see the site, went past it and got confused and had to call the host.
If the host posts clear photos of this site, provides better instructions to find it, and discounts the cost a bit for site to reflect the less than ideal location, I think site #3 could still be worth it for folks just looking for a quick place to stop along the way. I hope he updates the listing accordingly. Until then, buyer beware.